| FMRS | 47 / 100 · D | 84 / 100 · B | 79 / 100 · B |
|---|
| Reliability | 7 / 20 | 17 / 20 | 12 / 20 |
|---|
| Security and permissions | 8 / 20 | 16 / 20 | 18 / 20 |
|---|
| Maintenance | 9 / 20 | 16 / 20 | 15 / 20 |
|---|
| Documentation | 11 / 20 | 17 / 20 | 19 / 20 |
|---|
| Setup experience | 12 / 20 | 18 / 20 | 15 / 20 |
|---|
| Best for | - Claude Desktop users needing fast file operations
- Developers handling large files or streaming data
- Scenarios requiring backups and fault-tolerant editing
- Automated file management and sync tasks
| - Local assistants that need to work inside explicitly approved directories
- Individuals and development teams that want path-based data boundaries
| - Serious Obsidian users who want AI agents reading and writing their vault
- Users wanting self-hosted, plugin-free operation with no external APIs
- Mobile/multi-device workflows accessing the vault remotely
- Security-conscious users (OAuth 2.1, atomic writes, container hardening)
|
|---|
| Not for | - Environments with high security requirements that distrust third-party MCP servers
- Remote scenarios requiring network transport (e.g., SSE or HTTP)
- Fully offline environments without Node.js
- Needs for graphical interface or interactive file management
| - Highly sensitive environments that cannot allow model access to local file contents
- Shared remote file-service use cases
| - Users unwilling to run Docker or self-host a server
- Non-Obsidian note tools (Notion, Logseq, etc.)
- Scenarios requiring only a stdio local process without an HTTP server
- Remote multi-device sync without an Obsidian Sync subscription (the remote image requires one)
|
|---|
| Required permissions | - Read/write filesystem: can read, write, modify, and delete files and directories
- Create backup files (if enabled)
- Execute commands: via `npx`
- Access network (for installation)
| - Read access to every local directory listed in the configuration
- Filesystem write access when write or move tools are enabled
| - Read/write access to the Obsidian vault folder (bind mount /vault, rw)
- Persistent /data volume (search index, OAuth token DB, logs)
- MCP_AUTH_TOKEN as Bearer token (also the JWT signing key)
- Obsidian Sync token for headless sync in remote mode
- Local download of embedding/reranker models (~45MB total), no external API calls
|
|---|
| Risks and side effects | - File operations may cause data loss or overwrites, despite backup mechanisms
- Malicious prompts could induce unintended operations, requiring user confirmation
- Third-party server may contain vulnerabilities
- Improper allowed directories configuration may expose sensitive files
| - Sensitive files inside an allowed directory may enter model context
- Write and move tools change real files; keep scopes narrow and maintain backups
| - The server can read and write personal notes — guard MCP_AUTH_TOKEN carefully; leaking it exposes the whole vault
- Writes to real note files; despite atomic writes and protected paths, misconfiguration can alter data
- OAuth token DB lives on the /data volume; container compromise could expose valid sessions
- Remote deployments expose a public port — set PUBLIC_URL and reverse proxy correctly
- The remote image bundles proprietary obsidian-headless (not MIT-licensed); requires an active Obsidian Sync subscription
|
|---|
| Supported clients | Claude Desktop | Claude Desktop, Cursor, Cline, Windsurf | Claude Code, Claude Desktop, Claude.ai, Cursor, OpenCode, MCP Inspector |
|---|
| Tools | 26 | 6 | 30 |
|---|