← Back to directory
COMPARE UP TO 4 SERVERS

Compare MCP servers

Compare scores, permissions, risks, and fit in one decision-focused table.

DimensionDocker MCP GatewayDocker's official MCP gateway CLI plugin for managing and running MCP servers.GitHub MCP ServerGitHub's official MCP server for managing repos, issues, PRs, and workflows via natural language
FMRS68 / 100 · C76 / 100 · B
Reliability10 / 2013 / 20
Security and permissions15 / 2014 / 20
Maintenance18 / 2018 / 20
Documentation14 / 2017 / 20
Setup experience11 / 2014 / 20
Best for
  • Developers using Docker Desktop who want to simplify MCP server deployment and management.
  • Teams needing to manage multiple MCP servers under a single gateway with consistent configuration and monitoring.
  • Environments requiring containerized MCP servers to minimize host privileges.
  • Teams that want an AI assistant to directly operate on GitHub repos and collaboration workflows
  • Users already in the GitHub Copilot ecosystem who want a zero-deployment remote option
Not for
  • Developers not using Docker.
  • Scenarios needing direct execution of local npx or uvx servers without containerization.
  • Users seeking a lightweight MCP client independent of Docker Desktop.
  • Scenarios where you don't want the assistant to have write access to repos (enable only read-only toolsets)
  • Environments with strict network isolation for private repos that can't reach the official remote endpoint
Required permissions
  • Requires access to the Docker daemon to run and manage containers.
  • Reads and writes local configuration files (e.g., ~/.docker/config.json).
  • Accesses Docker Desktop's secret management for storing credentials.
  • May initiate OAuth flows, requiring network access.
  • A personal access token (PAT) or OAuth App token; effective scope depends on the token's own permissions
  • Enabling toolsets like actions/issues/pull_requests grants write access — request tokens on a least-privilege basis
Risks and side effects
  • Container images may contain malicious code; be cautious with untrusted MCP servers.
  • Improper secret management could leak API keys.
  • Misconfiguration of the gateway can lead to client connection failures or incorrect tool access.
  • Potential version compatibility issues due to reliance on Docker Desktop and CLI plugin.
  • Write toolsets (creating/merging PRs, triggering workflows) can cause accidental changes if the token is overscoped — try a read-only toolset first
  • In hosted mode, credentials travel via the Authorization header — make sure the client-to-api.githubcopilot.com connection is trusted
Supported clientsClaude Desktop, Claude Code, VS Code, Cursor, Windsurf, JetBrains IDEs, Zed, Amp
Tools015