- Reliability 10/20
- The README describes fairly complete startup, debugging, and failure-handling flows, but the server manifest is not cached and the supplied material contains no CI, committed tests, or executable evidence for the MCP initialization and tool-list handshake. Dependence on system Chrome, Node.js, optional CloakBrowser downloads, and external CDP endpoints also creates additional failure modes, so the score stays below the static-review ceiling of 12.
- Security and permissions 9/20
- The documentation explicitly discloses exposure of browser content, cookies, scripts, network data, and local files to the MCP client, and describes controls such as allowedRoots, real-path boundary checks, restrictive log permissions, and explicit confirmation for clearing network data. However, local file access is unrestricted by default, the persistent profile retains login state, evaluate_script can execute page JavaScript, and allowedRoots is optional. Least privilege and sensitive-data isolation are therefore incomplete. The supplied material does not establish a red-line risk.
- Maintenance 11/20
- The repository is not archived, declares Apache-2.0, and documents a maintainer-provided offline routing evaluation with 30 contracts. However, the material provides no commit history, release record, dependency-update policy, issue-response evidence, or security-reporting channel. The 9 open issues are only a limited discovery signal and do not demonstrate sustained maintenance, so points are deducted.
- Documentation 15/20
- The README covers installation, mainstream MCP client configuration, tool categories, workflows, parameters, profiles, file access, anti-detection modes, troubleshooting, and security warnings. It also discloses the approximate CloakBrowser download size and that model evaluations may incur costs. The missing manifest, incomplete authentication details, incomplete parameter constraints, platform coverage, and lack of verifiable implementation evidence prevent a full score.
- Setup experience 14/20
- The project provides npx, local-build instructions, and configuration examples for Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, and VS Code Copilot, with clear Node.js and Chrome prerequisites. The default path is short, but it requires a prepared runtime and Chrome; --cloak adds a binary download, while --browserUrl, third-party-browser CDP setup, and local-file permission configuration may be fragile. Full marks are therefore not justified.