- Reliability 8/20
- The README describes stdio startup, the tool set, transaction handling, and safety flows, but provides no reviewable server manifest, source code, committed tests, or real CI test evidence. Because this is a static-only review, MCP initialization, tool-list consistency, dependency behavior, and error paths cannot be verified, so the score is well below the high-reliability range.
- Security and permissions 12/20
- The evidence describes environment-based credential configuration, default safe mode, SQL risk classification, two-step confirmation for dangerous operations, and blocking of extreme actions such as project deletion. Points are deducted because the manifest and source are unavailable, so credential exposure, arbitrary Management API boundaries, log data scope, least privilege, and enforcement of confirmations cannot be verified. Database writes and Auth Admin capabilities also create significant side effects.
- Maintenance 5/20
- The README explicitly states that the author is no longer actively maintaining the project and recommends Supabase's official server instead. The repository is not archived and uses Apache-2.0, with a changelog, but there is no evidence of current maintenance, dependency updates, a response process, or a security disclosure channel; maintenance activity is therefore low.
- Documentation 14/20
- The README covers installation, runtime requirements, environment variables, regions, connection types, several client configurations, features, risk levels, limitations, and troubleshooting. Points are deducted because tool parameters and return contracts are not documented systematically, the server manifest is missing, some instructions depend on an external service and unverified package behavior, and cost, data-retention, and security-review details are absent.
- Setup experience 11/20
- The documentation provides pipx, uv, and source-install paths, plus configuration examples for Cursor, Windsurf, Claude Desktop, and Cline with platform-specific path guidance. Points are deducted for the Python 3.12+ requirement, an additional QUERY_API_KEY dependency, multiple Supabase credentials, region-specific configuration, and manual absolute-path setup for some clients. No verifiable CI, test, or actual startup evidence is provided, leaving the setup materially fragile.